Many public health advocates have thrown their support to what seems to be a political twofer. Dec 29, 2008 new york state plans to fight obesity by taxing sugary soft drinks. Urges tax on sugary drinks to fight obesity the new. Why are we experiencing an epidemic of obesity in this country. Taxing sugary sodas could help fight childhood obesity.
Doctors demand a 20% tax on sugary drinks to fight uk obesity. Obesity is merely a proxy for health outcomes, much as soda is a proxy for obesity. New york state plans to fight obesity by taxing sugary soft drinks. Is a soda tax the solution to americas obesity problem.
Jan 11, 2012 the most contentious issue that arises from lopezs study, though, is the role of government policy. Jul, 2015 britains doctors are calling for the government to impose a 20% tax on sugarsweetened drinks to pay for subsidies on fruit and vegetables in an effort to slow the obesity epidemic. Malaysia, which faces a national obesity crisis, is studying mexicos tax on sugary beverages as a model for one of its own. The governor estimated that this tax would reduce the consumption of these affected beverages by 5%. A tool for obesity prevention, cost savings and health. Theyve helped reduce smoking, and are now targeting sugary drinks. Health experts believe the obesity crisis has become an. The obesity epidemic is one of those rare books that can genuinely change the world. Mar 23, 2016 obesity is merely a proxy for health outcomes, much as soda is a proxy for obesity. Tax soda to fight obesity, who urges nations around the. Humiliation, the soda tax, and deadweight loss marginal. The salt a world health organization report recommends fiscal policies.
Over the past decade, initiatives to reduce consumption of sugar drinks have. An illustration of sin taxes depicted by bottles and cups of soda. Oct 01, 2010 the obesity epidemic is one of those rare books that can genuinely change the world. Briony harris, will a sugar tax help reduce obesity. Advocates point to a number of recent studies in that conclude that sugary drinks have a lot to do with why. In fact, there are good reasons to think it unlikely that the tax will do anything meaningful to reduce obesity. But most use the proceeds to fight litter, not the epidemic of overweight children in u. Can taxing sugary drinks help fight the obesity epidemic. The effects of obesity on american adults and children 12 words 5 pages. Health experts believe the obesity crisis has become an epidemic that needs to be controlled. Tax soda to fight obesity, who urges nations around the globe. Sugarsweetened beverages ssbs contribute to this excess energy intake in children and adults, are linked with obesity, diabetes and dental caries, and are an increasing focus of public health attention.
The antisoda movement has been brewing for several years, and now 2016 is looking like it could be the biggest year for taxing soda yet. But the sweetenedbeverage industry is not about to go away. The author of this article uses very sloppy language to get to a pc conclusion that she obviously supports. Soda taxes work, studies suggest but maybe not as well. We fully support colagiuris appeal to implement comprehensive, regulatory action to reduce sugarsweetened beverage consumption. Tax soda to fight obesity, who urges nations around. Governments consider new taxes on soda and candy for a pdf of the full study, click here. With obesity and other dietrelated diseases, such as type 2 diabetes, disproportionately affecting poor, minority communities48 percent of african americans are obese, for. As pandemic wrecks budgets, states cut and borrow to balance books. There are so many factors contributing to obesity, although some are more prominent than others. While obesity is a complex condition with many contributing factors, a relative excessive kilojoule intake is a major driver of weight gain.
Apr 05, 2016 britains new soda taxing policy to beat obesity. Medina says its been that way ever since philadelphia passed its controversial soda tax, which bumped up prices on sweetened drinks by 1. In particular, lopez views a sales tax on high calorie soft drinks as one key weapon in the. While these sugary and saltladen foods may not be good for your health, the scientists found no significant difference in how much of these foods. Two of the countrys leading medical groups on monday issued a call to arms against the soda industry, urging legislators and policymakers to embrace taxes, warning labels and advertising. Shots health news the childhood obesity epidemic rages on in the united states, with a big. In fact, in the 1970s, teens drank about twice as much milk as soda. A dc tax that would have funded more healthful school lunches was killed by the council in may. A majority of americans support taxing sugary drinks to fund preschool and childrens health programs, a new poll from politico and the harvard t. Can soda tax curb obesity northwestern university news. Two top medical groups call for soda taxes and advertising.
T he antisoda movement has been brewing for several years, and now 2016 is looking like it could be the biggest year for taxing soda yet. Soft drink consumption has been hypothesized as one of the major factors in the growing rates of obesity in the us. And, since most obese children grow into obese adults, the tax could eventually reduce obesity among adults too. The weight of the nation by john hoffman, judith a. Taxing the manufacturers presents the greatest opportunity to curb the actual effects of obesity and could help generate significant revenue. So its hardly surprising when government officials want to fight obesity by raising taxes, especially by taxing sugarsweetened beverages a socalled soda tax. Obesity has been labeled as an ongoing epidemic in the us and many other. Taxing soda to slow the obesity epidemic the nutrition. The obesity epidemic has been hyped and blown out of proportion, 2. Research finds soda tax does little to decrease obesity. Nearly twothirds of all states currently tax soft drinks using excise taxes, sales taxes, or special exemptions to food exemptions from sales taxes to reduce consumption of this product, raise revenue, and improve public health.
Yet, evidence continues to mount that taxing sugary beverages could help to stem or even reverse the american obesity epidemic. Oct 11, 2016 tax soda to fight obesity, who urges nations around the globe. Regardless of what else soda taxes might achieve, theres no evidence to date that. Taxing soda to slow the obesity epidemic adding a penny per ounce tax to sugarsweetened beverages could slow the growth of obesity in the u. One, limit where and when simple carbohydrates can be used it worked in world war ii. Urges tax on sugary drinks to fight obesity the new york. Frances book and start looking at ways to limit access to ssbs. Jun 29, 2011 to many, a tax on soda is a nobrainer in advancing the nations war on obesity.
Food swamps, not food deserts, may be to blame for obesity. The salt a world health organization report recommends fiscal policies, including taxes, that hike the retail price of sugary drinks. Taxes on sugarsweetened beverages to reduce overweight and obesity in middleincome countries. Part ii discusses and critiques the first argument, that government should recoup some of the disproportionately high health care costs of obesity by taxing soda or junk food. The usda report is not evidence that a soda tax will reduce obesity, it is simply speculation and predictions. The world health organization on tuesday urged countries to impose a tax on sugary drinks to battle the growing obesity epidemic and presented new. The first tax on soda was implemented in 1920 in order to raise revenue. Mar 21, 2016 t he anti soda movement has been brewing for several years, and now 2016 is looking like it could be the biggest year for taxing soda yet.
The most contentious issue that arises from lopezs study, though, is the role of government policy. The primary sources for this collection effort include the book of the states. Obesity is now usually defined using a formula known as the body mass index bmi, in which weight in kilograms is divided by height in meters squared. Mar 16, 2018 in fact, there are good reasons to think it unlikely that the tax will do anything meaningful to reduce obesity. This part also explores alternative economic arguments for. Britains doctors are calling for the government to impose a 20% tax on sugarsweetened drinks to pay for subsidies on fruit and vegetables in an effort to slow the obesity epidemic. A person with a bmi of 25 or above is generally considered overweight. Sep 16, 2009 the problem is that its not clear whether there is a similar linear relationship between soda and obesity, or that one can be established without first taxing sugared soda out of existence and. Soda taxes are not a sensible solution to combat obesity tax.
The problem is that its not clear whether there is a similar linear relationship between soda and obesity, or that one can be established without first taxing sugared soda out of existence and. In 1951, west virginia imposed an excise tax on bottled soft drinks. Aug 28, 2014 and, since most obese children grow into obese adults, the tax could eventually reduce obesity among adults too. Doctors demand a 20% tax on sugary drinks to fight uk. The sequence of effects linking soft drink taxes to obesity include 1 the tax increase.
Obesity is a serious and complex problem, but a tax on soft drinks, which contribute just 2 per cent of the total calories in the average diet, will not help address it, said gavin partington, director general of the british soft drinks association, in a statement. A sweetened beverage tax is needed to combat the obesity. The graphs and tables show a stunning increase in obesity levels at the turn of the 1980s and obesity literally takes off, like an aeroplane trajectory, from that point onwards. The obesity epidemic, science, morality and ideology is not light reading. The effect of state level soda tax background on adult obesity. The tab comes in obvious ways, like increased health care costs, and less obvious ways, like decreased fuel efficiency. And indeed one can develop foodconsumption related illness without being obese.
Rising obesity is a threat to public health, and taxing sugarsweetened beverages ssbs in order to reduce consumption and thus caloric intake could be a viable policy response. Apr 25, 2016 with obesity and other dietrelated diseases, such as type 2 diabetes, disproportionately affecting poor, minority communities48 percent of african americans are obese, for example, compared. Wouldnt the most efficient solution be taxing people for adverse health outcomes, or not subsidizing them. A constructive critique of public health arguments for. Last week, new york legislators, who had pioneered the idea, caved in to the powerful beverage lobby. If governments tax products like sugary drinks, they can reduce suffering and. Besides promoting obesity and disease, soft drinks displace from the diet real foods with valuable healthpromoting nutrients. Taxing sugary drinks could put dent in obesity epidemic. But losing weight requires personal commitment mon 29 dec 2008 15. When it comes to obesity, many studies focus on food deserts that is, lowincome areas where more than onethird of the population lives over 1 mile away from a grocery store but as olga khazan reports for the atlantic, new research suggests food deserts may not be the culprit instead, it finds food swamps areas with a high density of fast food and junk food are a likelier cause. Advocates point to a number of studies in recent years that conclude that sugary drinks have a lot to do with why americans are getting fatter.
Taxing sin foods obesity prevention and public health. Justifications for recent soda taxes are varied and include raising revenue for the general fund, using revenue to for obesity prevention education, and deterring individuals from drinking soda in order to lower the rates of obesity. After the first 15 months of the tax, prices of soda increased by 12%. When philadelphia was considering its soda pop tax, harvard researchers ran a study that found the tax could help 36,000 people per year avoid obesity, prevent 2,280 annual cases of diabetes.
Junk food not to blame for americas obesity epidemic. Just pass a tax that covers an entire state or maybe even a whole. The first choice is legislatively improbable and not within the governments jurisdiction but the second could work. New data from soda taxes in berkeley and philadelphia present a mixed. It just needs to be read with an open mind and a desire to help our fellow human beings. Even if research suggests it might work, however, the idea of a federal soda tax.
National health and nutrition examination survey data indicates that when individuals reduce soda consumption due to soda tax increases, they. They do indicate at the very least that the tax could help to prevent continued growth of the obesity epidemic, if the tax rate is set sufficiently. List of books and articles about obesity online research. Taxing soda is an increasingly popular approach to raising revenue while combating obesity, which affects 40 percent of american adults. Proposals are on the table in california and philadelphia. Mar 25, 2019 two of the countrys leading medical groups on monday issued a call to arms against the soda industry, urging legislators and policymakers to embrace taxes, warning labels and advertising. To many, a tax on soda is a nobrainer in advancing the nations war on obesity. Oct 12, 2016 the world health organization on tuesday urged countries to impose a tax on sugary drinks to battle the growing obesity epidemic and presented new data on the beneficial health effects of such a tax. Soda tax advocates, meanwhile, say that theres a simple way to keep people from avoiding the tax by going outside the city.
The authors, university physical educators in australia, have packed an enormous amount of research and thought into this volume. Rather, the purpose of soda taxes is to staunch the rise in obesity among those who live in the taxed area. As the united states struggles to combat obesity, some health policy experts have asserted that a tax on sugarsweetened beverages such as soda would lead to reduced consumption of sodas and. Oct 15, 2009 taxing soda to slow the obesity epidemic adding a penny per ounce tax to sugarsweetened beverages could slow the growth of obesity in the u. Taxes on sugarsweetened beverages to reduce overweight. Obesity in the uk, as an example, increases almost 10 fold between the 1970s and 1999 from 2. This tax has been referred to as the soda tax and the obesity tax. Aug 12, 20 obesity is a serious and complex problem, but a tax on soft drinks, which contribute just 2 per cent of the total calories in the average diet, will not help address it, said gavin partington, director general of the british soft drinks association, in a statement. Taxing a nutrient, calorie content or ingredient does not address the primary drivers of obesity since, for example, not all calories are equal. Whats happening now whats next books podcasts crisis response sponsored. All we can eat usda says soda tax would cut obesity. A soda tax in new york city championed by mayor michael r. Sugary soda tax not enough to halt the march of obesity in.
1030 580 1108 1214 525 1531 1511 1303 183 1346 1571 1309 515 1178 816 747 756 873 1468 1545 1280 1394 355 91 1300 606 600 546 692 1038 997 890 65 1379 29 756 1092 279 1230 140 1491 877 600 1264 1478 1463 880 1489 531 931 666